On-premises vs. Cloud: Which One Is The Best For Your Business Model?

In this article, you will learn:

• Understanding the Fundamentals of On-premises and Cloud
• 8 Factors to Consider Before Making a Decision between Cloud and On-premises!
• On-premises vs Cloud Comparison Table
• Making the Shift With StormIT’s AWS Migration Services

Gartner predicts that by 2026, 75% of organizations will base their digital transformation model on the cloud as the fundamental platform. The public cloud spending is forecasted to reach 724 Billion USD in 2024. The statistics depict exponential growth, but, choosing the right infrastructure remains one of the most crucial decisions for organizations, necessitating consideration of different factors. Can we afford the cost of On-premises? Are we ready to potentially risk security with the cloud? Can we manage the high responsibility of updates and maintenance On-premises? And so many more…

Both options involve significant trade-offs, thus, to smoothen your dilemma, this blog walks you down the differences between On-premises and cloud, their features, use cases, and potential challenges to help you make an informed decision. Read through.

Understanding the Fundamentals of On-premises and Cloud

Before moving to the contrasting features, it is crucial to understand the basics of both and why they are used.

What is the On-premises model?

The On-premises model involves deploying and managing software directly within an organization's own infrastructure. Unlike cloud-based solutions, On-premises systems are installed and operate on servers owned, maintained, and housed by the organization itself. The setup requirement involves

• All the necessary IT equipment, including storage servers, CPUs, routers, server racks, cooling units, and a sufficient power source to ensure smooth and uninterrupted operations.
• An appropriate physical space to house these servers, ensuring they are kept in optimal conditions to prevent overheating and other potential issues.
• Dedicated staff members responsible for maintaining, protecting, and monitoring the system. These individuals ensure that the software runs efficiently, security measures are upheld, and any issues or malfunctions are addressed promptly.

The On-premises model is favored by businesses seeking control and customization, especially those in sectors with stringent data security and compliance requirements, such as finance, healthcare, and government. These entities often prioritize direct oversight of their data and system configurations. While the On-premises approach comes with upfront hardware and software costs, it also necessitates a rigorous approach to disaster recovery and handling potential downtime.

What is the Cloud Computing model?

Cloud computing refers to the delivery of computing services—like storage, processing, and networking—over the internet, facilitated by third-party Cloud service providers (CSPs) such as Amazon Web Services (AWS), Microsoft Azure, Google Cloud Platform, and IBM Cloud.

With cloud solutions, the need for physical hardware is significantly reduced, as the infrastructure is provided by the cloud provider. From databases to machine learning tools, everything is taken care of by the vendor, reducing the need for in-house software management.

Businesses and individuals adopt cloud solutions for scalability, flexibility, and cost savings. Instead of incurring substantial capital expenses on hardware, users can leverage these platforms on a pay-as-you-go or subscription basis. While the cloud offers immense advantages, users must place trust in these providers to ensure security, compliance, and consistent uptime.

8 Factors to Consider Before Making a Decision between Cloud and On-premises!

Cloud versus On-premises is a vast topic, but to make an informed decision here are the primary factors you should consider:

On-premises vs Cloud: Location & Accessibility

• On-premises:

On-premises means that everything is located on-site or within the organization's immediate infrastructure. Your software and data reside on servers that are either owned or rented, and they're typically housed within a facility associated with the business. You can easily access it by directly connecting to your internal network.

• Cloud:

With the cloud, your software and data are on servers managed by a third party. These servers can be anywhere in the world. You can access it from anywhere with an internet connection. For remote access, VPN solutions like site-to-site VPNs and Direct-connect can help you with secured links between on-premises and cloud infrastructures, offering high-speed, dedicated connections to cloud data centers. This is great for businesses with teams in different places or people who travel or work from home.

What do you need to consider?

If your organization operates across multiple locations or has frequent remote access needs, a cloud solution can be particularly beneficial due to its inherent accessibility. Both cloud and On-premises solutions offer robust data control and access restriction capabilities. However, businesses seeking direct oversight and a more hands-on approach to data management might find an On-premises infrastructure aligns better with their preferences.

On-premises vs Cloud: Cost

• On-premises:

On-premises setups require a significant upfront cost. This includes purchasing hardware, software licenses, and any infrastructure setup. After the initial set-up, the operational expenses are also on a higher end. These include maintenance, power, cooling, potential system upgrades, and the salaries offered to the maintenance staff. In case of default, repair or replacement costs may also be incurred. The responsibility of total maintenance falls on the organization.

• Cloud:

Is cloud cheaper than On-premises? Yes, will be an obvious answer. Cloud models have a significant upfront cost advantage. There's no need for extensive hardware purchases or setting up a dedicated data center. Some minor setup fees might be required, but they're far less than On-premises installations. The maintenance and upgrade costs are also generally covered by the service provider. However, as cloud models often operate on a subscription basis (monthly, annually, or usage-based), the cumulative cost over time can be substantial for expanding businesses. To address this, AWS offers different pricing models and saving opportunities like reserved instances, spot instances, AWS Savings plan, and many others, enabling users to secure discounts through extended commitments, potentially optimizing cloud costs in the long run.

What do you need to consider?

Consider your budget now and in the future. If you can handle a bigger upfront cost and potentially lower costs over time, On-premises might be right for you. But if you want to start with a smaller investment and are okay with regular fees, the cloud could be a better fit. Always factor in potential growth or changes in your business, as these can affect costs down the line.

On-premises vs Cloud: Control & Customization

• On-premises:

On-premises solutions provide organizations with a high level of control over their systems and data. Since everything is housed within the company's infrastructure, there's direct oversight of data, system configurations, and security measures. You can easily tailor the model for individual business needs. Whether it's integrating with other in-house systems or making bespoke modifications, On-premises setups offer a degree of flexibility that's hard to match.

• Cloud:

Cloud environments, especially public cloud setups, might offer slightly less control. While there's still a significant degree of oversight, some aspects are managed by the service provider, which means businesses might have to adapt to the provider's configurations and policies. In the context of configurations, service providers offer incredible scalability and broad applicability. However, there might be limitations when it comes to deep customization or integration with specific in-house systems.

What do you need to consider?

If having granular control and the ability to make deep customizations is essential for you, On-premises might be the way forward. However, if you're looking for a solution that's easy to scale and offers a balance between control and convenience, the cloud could be more appropriate.

On-premises vs Cloud: Security

• On-premises:

Organizations have full control over their security measures, allowing them to implement specific protocols tailored to their needs. They have the autonomy to decide on, implement, and manage a wide range of security measures, including network security strategies, firewalls, intrusion detection systems, access controls, encryption, and network segmentation. However, this control is a double-edged sword. The ability to alter security measures as per your needs comes under one of the biggest advantages but the responsibility of securing the infrastructure invites too much time, effort, and responsibility, which in itself is a big disadvantage.

• Cloud:

Cloud solutions offer robust security measures backed by the expertise of dedicated providers. These providers invest heavily in state-of-the-art defenses, ensuring data protection across distributed infrastructures. However, the shared responsibility model in cloud security means that while the provider manages infrastructure security, clients must secure their data and applications. This shared model can sometimes lead to ambiguity in roles, making it crucial for organizations to clearly understand their security responsibilities in cloud environments.

What do you need to consider?

To evaluate cloud vs On-premises security, consider granularity. If you need granular control over every aspect of security and are most importantly, comfortable with the responsibility of securing the whole environment, On-premises might be the better choice. However, if you're looking for a solution that provides advanced security measures with less hands-on management, the cloud could be more appropriate.

On-premises vs Cloud: Scalability & Flexibility

• On-premises:

On-premises solutions have limitations when it comes to scaling. Expanding capacity, whether horizontally or vertically, requires purchasing new hardware components, causing potential downtime and impacting business agility. Similarly, scaling down is a challenge as reducing capacity in On-premises setups means deactivating servers and potentially wasting resources that were previously invested.

• Cloud:

One of the cloud's primary advantages is its inherent scalability. One of the cloud's primary advantages is its inherent scalability. Organizations can quickly scale up or down based on their needs, often within minutes, without significant downtime. With the almost infinite possibility to grow within minutes, cloud providers not only offer auto-scaling features that adjust resources automatically based on current demands or workload patterns but also enable multi-region and availability zone (AZ) deployments. These AZ and multi-zone capabilities ensure data redundancy, and higher availability, and further enhance the scalability potential, making the cloud ideal for fluctuating workloads and expansive growth.

What do you need to consider?

When considering scalability and flexibility, evaluate your workloads' potential growth and variability. If rapid scaling or the ability to handle fluctuating demands is crucial, the cloud offers a clear advantage. On the other hand, if your infrastructure needs are relatively static, On-premises might suffice, though it comes with its set of scaling challenges.

On-premises vs Cloud: Performance

• On-premises:

On-premises setups, being local, offer zero latency, making hosted applications highly responsive for on-site users. Moreover, organizations have the freedom to fine-tune performance based on specific needs. But, similar to the security parameter, On-premises performance has its own pros and cons. You being the single tenant, performance is on the higher end, but achieving the same requires significant investment in equipment and skilled technicians for optimization.

• Cloud:

Cloud providers offer a range of optimized compute instances tailored to diverse needs, ensuring efficient performance for various workloads, both for databases and computing. Not only can users benefit from the vast selection of performance-optimized instances and the ability to swiftly switch between them, but they can also leverage caching services that can be activated in mere seconds. Adjusting instance size/type, memory type, or even transitioning to a faster variant can significantly enhance the performance. While occasional network latency might be a consideration, the flexibility and customization options offered by cloud providers, especially for databases, which play a pivotal role in many applications, are a compelling advantage.

What do you need to consider?

Consider the performance demands of your workloads and the resources available for optimization. On-premises might offer peak performance but require hands-on management and investment, while the cloud provides flexibility with potential variability in performance.

On-premises vs Cloud: Compliance

• On-premises:

Many organizations today operate under regulatory frameworks, irrespective of their industry. Common regulations include the Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act (HIPAA) for private health information, and the Family Educational Rights and Privacy Act (FERPA) for student records, among others. The On-premises model is favored by businesses seeking control and customization, especially those in sectors with stringent data security and compliance requirements, such as finance, healthcare, and government. On-premises solutions offer this direct oversight, ensuring that companies can easily adhere to industry-specific mandates. But, constant eye is required to ensure you are updated.

• Cloud:

When opting for cloud solutions, enterprises must exercise thorough due diligence. Choosing prominent and reliable third-party cloud providers like AWS can be advantageous, as they are known for their robust security and compliance measures, ensuring adherence to the regulatory mandates relevant to various industries. In fact, AWS provides detailed insights on their compliance efforts, which can be thoroughly evaluated to make an informed decision. While cloud providers typically offer robust security and compliance measures, the responsibility for ensuring that sensitive data remains secure and that compliance regulations are upheld often falls under the Shared Responsibility Model.

What do you need to consider?

Consider the regulatory demands of your industry. On-premises offers direct oversight and control, making adherence straightforward, but demands continuous monitoring and management. In contrast, the cloud necessitates a collaborative approach with providers, offering streamlined compliance solutions but requiring due diligence and shared responsibility.

On-premises vs Cloud: Disaster Recovery

• On-premises:

On-premises solutions enable organizations to design and implement disaster recovery (DR) plans tailored to their unique needs. This often involves setting up redundant systems, regular backups, and failover mechanisms. Since the infrastructure is on-site, organizations can have direct access to backup hardware and data storage, potentially speeding up recovery times after a disaster. However, establishing a robust DR plan On-premises can be resource-intensive, requiring dedicated hardware, specialized software, and skilled personnel to manage and test the DR processes.

• Cloud:

Numerous cloud providers offer built-in disaster recovery features like automated backups, geo-redundancy, and failover services, ensuring data integrity and availability. These DR solutions can be scaled based on the organization's needs, allowing for flexibility in terms of recovery time objectives (RTO) and recovery point objectives (RPO). Additionally, leveraging cloud providers' DR solutions can be more cost-effective, eliminating the need for significant upfront investments in dedicated DR hardware and software.

What do you need to consider?

Consider the criticality of your data and applications and the acceptable downtime in case of a disaster. While On-premises offers tailored DR solutions, it demands significant resources. The cloud, on the other hand, provides scalable and cost-effective DR solutions, but it's essential to ensure they align with your business continuity requirements.

On-premises vs Cloud Comparison Table

Here’s a visual sum-up of the primary differences between On-premises and cloud models.

Making the Shift With StormIT’s AWS Migration Services

Choosing between On-premises or cloud is not a one-size-fits-all decision. On-premises solutions offer unparalleled control, direct oversight, and deep customization. In contrast, cloud platforms bring forward scalability, flexibility, and often a more favorable cost structure over time. For many businesses, a hybrid cloud approach has served as a great initial step, blending the best of both worlds as they transition or experiment with cloud capabilities. The optimal choice is deeply rooted in an organization's unique requirements, future growth plans, and the value they place on aspects like control, cost, and adaptability.

But, if you have made the decision to move to a cloud-based model StormIT’s AWS Migration Services are the perfect fit for you. From assessing your business needs to planning and executing the migration, we work closely with you at every stage of the migration journey. Accelerate your time to value and improve cost efficiency with AWS cloud and StormIT’s migration services.

Contact us