Amazon EKS Autoscaling: How to Optimize Your Cluster with Cluster Autoscaler and Karpenter

Efficient resource management is vital for businesses scaling their applications in Amazon EKS. Tools like Cluster Autoscaler and Karpenter enable you to dynamically adjust your Kubernetes cluster, ensuring it can handle workload demands while keeping costs under control. Dive into how these autoscaling solutions work and find out which one aligns best with your EKS setup.

In this article, you will learn:

• Overview of EKS Autoscaling
• Overview of Cluster Autoscaler
• Overview of AWS Karpenter
• Karpenter vs Cluster Autoscaler: Key Differences

As businesses grow and application traffic spikes, the need for efficient resource management becomes crucial. Amazon Elastic Kubernetes Service (EKS) provides a robust framework for deploying, managing, and scaling containerized applications using Kubernetes.

The integration of autoscaling tools like Cluster Autoscaler and Karpenter within EKS environments is essential for optimizing resource allocation in real-time. These tools can automatically scale up or scale down the number of nodes in a Kubernetes cluster based on current needs, which helps organizations maintain performance levels without overspending on idle resources. This capability is particularly valuable in managing peak loads and ensuring that applications remain responsive without manual intervention. The adoption of EKS scaling solutions is on the rise as more companies recognize their potential to reduce costs and increase operational efficiency.

This blog will explore how autoscaling enhances the functionality of Amazon EKS and understand the fundamentals of Cluster Autoscaler and Karpenter. Read on to explore the details of Karpenter vs Cluster Autoscaler.

Overview of EKS Autoscaling

Image Source: Amazon Elastic Kubernetes Service (EKS)

What is Autoscaling in EKS?

Autoscaling in Amazon Elastic Kubernetes Service (EKS) refers to the method of dynamically adjusting the resources within an EKS cluster to align closely with the workload demands. This automatic scaling ensures that the cluster operates with the optimal number of nodes and pods, enhancing both performance and cost efficiency. In EKS, autoscaling is designed to provide seamless scalability by monitoring and adjusting the computing resources as needed, without requiring manual adjustments from the administrators.

Types of Autoscaling in EKS

There are two primary components of autoscaling in EKS:

• Cluster Autoscaler: This component adjusts the number of nodes in the cluster. It monitors the usage of individual nodes and scales the number of nodes up or down depending on whether existing resources are insufficient or under-utilized, ensuring that there are enough nodes to run all pods but not so many that resources go to waste.

• Horizontal Pod Autoscaler (HPA): HPA scales the number of pods in a deployment or replica set. It adjusts the volume of pod replicas based on the observed CPU utilization or other select metrics provided through the Kubernetes Metrics Server.

For the purpose of this article, the focus will be primarily on EKS kubernetes node autoscaling using Cluster Autoscaler and Karpenter.

Overview of Cluster Autoscaler

What is Cluster Autoscaler in EKS?

Designed to automatically adjust the number of nodes within an EKS cluster’s Auto Scaling Group (ASG) to meet the requirements of pods, Cluster Autoscaler is a key feature in Amazon Elastic Kubernetes Service (EKS). It aims to ensure that all pods have a place to run without leading to excessive unused capacity. This adjustment is done dynamically, scaling the nodes up or down based on actual pod usage, which enhances overall efficiency and performance.

Key Features

• Pod-Driven Scaling: AWS EKS Cluster Autoscaler responds to the demand by scaling up when pods cannot be scheduled due to a lack of resources, and scaling down when nodes are underutilized. This ensures that the cluster maintains only the necessary resources, reducing waste.

• Custom Scaling Policies: Users can define specific thresholds and scaling behaviors, including how the scaling should be balanced across different availability zones, to optimize resource distribution and application performance.

• Resource Optimization: It analyzes the resource usage trends and automatically adjusts the cluster size, promoting optimal utilization of computing resources.

• Graceful Node Termination: When scaling down, Cluster Autoscaler ensures a graceful termination of nodes, safely evacuating pods before decommissioning any infrastructure, which minimizes disruptions to running applications.

Advantages and Limitations of AWS EKS Cluster Autoscaler

• Advantages: EKS Cluster Autoscaler is easy to set up and integrates deeply with Kubernetes, making it a popular choice for automatic scaling within EKS environments. It is supported by a broad community and has proven effective in a variety of deployment scenarios.

• Limitations: Despite its benefits, Cluster Autoscaler offers limited flexibility in terms of scaling strategies and can have slower response times compared to newer, more adaptive tools like Karpenter. This can sometimes lead to less than optimal resource utilization and performance during rapid changes in workload.

Overview of AWS Karpenter

Image Source: AWS Karpenter

Understanding AWS Karpenter

An innovative, open-source autoscaler for Kubernetes, Karpenter is designed to optimize cluster performance and resource utilization. Unlike traditional autoscalers that may simply add or remove nodes based on predefined metrics, Karpenter dynamically launches the right-sized EC2 instances tailored to current workload demands. This approach allows for more precise scaling decisions, significantly enhancing resource utilization and operational efficiency.

Key Features of Karpenter

• Provisioning Based on Workload Needs: Karpenter assesses the requirements of the current workload and chooses the most suitable EC2 instances, considering factors like instance types and the use of spot or on-demand pricing options. This ensures that resources are perfectly matched to workload needs.

• Faster Scaling and Efficiency: AWS Karpenter can respond more rapidly to changes in workload than traditional scaling solutions, minimizing over-provisioning and thereby optimizing costs. This quick adaptability is crucial for workloads with variable demands.

• Improved Flexibility and Customization: Offers enhanced control over scaling activities, including features like workload consolidation and proactive de-provisioning of resources, which further reduce costs and improve efficiency.

Advantages and Limitations of Karpenter in EKS

• Advantages: AWS Karpenter is recognized for its agility and efficient scaling capabilities, making it a favored choice in dynamic environments. Its straightforward setup process facilitates rapid integration with Amazon EKS, while its ability to quickly respond to changes in workload ensures optimal resource allocation. The tool offers extensive customization options, allowing users to tailor their scaling strategies to specific needs.

• Limitations: Despite its strengths, AWS Karpenter's proactive scaling approach might lead to resource over-provisioning if not correctly configured, potentially increasing costs rather than saving them. Additionally, to fully benefit from its features, Karpenter requires continuous monitoring and adjustment, which may increase the operational burden on teams.

Karpenter vs Cluster Autoscaler: Key Differences

Final Thoughts

In conclusion, effectively managing EKS autoscaling is crucial for organizations aiming to optimize application performance and cost. Both Cluster Autoscaler and Karpenter provide powerful solutions to achieve these objectives. As you explore the potential of EKS autoscaling, consider the unique demands of your applications and the specific benefits each tool offers. Making the right choice will ensure that your infrastructure is both responsive and economical, aligning with your broader operational efficiency and scalability goals.

As you continue to develop and optimize your cloud strategy, follow StormIT’s blog for more valuable content on cloud technologies and best practices.